As all homeowners are invariably, painfully aware, painting, either interior or exterior, can be a very expensive proposition. In fact, it’s egregious to the point of near extortion to have it professionally done. Savvy folks also know that the cost of actual materials is relatively inexpensive and the skill required for a great job relatively low. So, when one hires this out, it means that one is paying a massive premium for an insanely high-margin for what amounts to relatively low-skilled labor.
This then begs the question, why do so many people hire professionals to paint their homes? It’s actually a very good one and, traditionally, for me, the deciding factor has always been time. To be sure, I’ve never hired a painter for interior projects as they are extraordinarily easy and can be knocked out in less than a day for a room or two. However, I’ve always hired out the exterior work as it is significantly more time intensive and it would otherwise take me many months trying to tackle the job exclusively on weekends.
DIY, BABY!
However, this is no longer the case as I now have all the time in the world. So, looking at the $7000 quote to have the exterior of Fate Estate painted, I figured I’d just do it myself. I’ve done quite a bit of painting in my day and, while I truly despise it with every fiber of my being, I’m actually really, really good at it. That said, that left me with no legitimate reason to pay someone without being consumed by the feeling of being a colossal, lazy sack of oatmeal.
It was pretty easy to estimate the materials cost by taking some measurements, identifying the paint I wanted and accounting for the few supplies I needed to get. Using the absolute best exterior paint on the market, I figured the job would cost about $600 (final cost was $642). That would save me about $6400. I don’t know about you, but, to me, that’s quite a bit of scratch. With that amount, I could, literally, fly 1st class to Tokyo, stay in a suite at the Ritz and eat at the finest sushi joints – for 10 consecutive days! Plus, pay the sitter for the cats, plus return with a few coins in my pocket.
Since the house, garage and studio were already unpainted and the siding pre-primed, the job would be less complex than a normal one that entails the usual washing & sanding involved in grueling and time consuming preparation. Most painters, with a sprayer, could knock this out in less than 40 total hours. For those paying attention, that translates to an hourly rate of $175 or the equivalent of an annual salary of $364,000. All that for, at best, semi-skilled labor, which gets me back to my original point.
So, full of vim, vigor, and visions of Tokyo sushi, off I went to procure my supplies. Flash forward over a month and 59 total hours later to when I finally completed the project. It looked absolutely stunning, but I had learned me quite a few lessons along the way.
A HEARTBREAKING CASE OF STAGGERING INEFFICIENCY
You’ll recall above when I mentioned the use of a sprayer, right? Arguably, the best method to get a lot of paint up pretty quickly, particularly on siding. Yeah, I didn’t use one. Why? Well, I hadn’t done so before, so I figured the learning curve would cost me time and opted to roll it instead. This also came with the bonus of a guarantee that I would not fuck it up. Plus, there was a tremendous amount of trim, fascia, and other work that would require a brush anyway. That said, using only rollers and brushes was diabolically inefficient. Insanely inefficient. In fact, if you exclude the roller, it is impossible to have been more inefficient.
While this was one excellent example of the inefficient aspect of my approach, it was not the best. The best was not spending the coin to rent some residential scaffolding and relying exclusively on ladders. Of the total 59 hours the project took me, I estimate that more than 50% of that time was climbing up/down and repositioning ladders. The only serendipitous benefit of this idiotic decision is that I no longer have any fear whatsoever at being 30′ off the ground supported by only my legs while my arms are splayed wide applying tape or paint in a gale-force wind. This, of course, may be offset by the possible future cost of PTSD counseling.
The last example of inefficiency was doing the project by myself. I, gratefully, had about 6 hours of help on the final, non-ladder trim, but it was, effectively a one-Fate show. This was a gargantuan mistake, even if I was able to write a number of blog articles in my head while doing so. Nevertheless, not asking for help is one of my 3.2 million personal flaws and foibles, and it really was to my detriment here.
MY MIND IS YOUNGER THAN MY BODY
This lesson did not come as any particular revelation. I am, and will always be, the age of 32 – in my mind. And, as it relates to my physicality, this is precisely how I behave. This is generally a good thing as it ensures that I never become paralyzed by fear of injuring myself engaging in ridiculous activities, and, as a result, I generally don’t.
However, it was not an insignificant slice of humble pie to learn that my body, at least to the extent that it involves crawling about on ladders, cannot be physically exerted beyond 5 hours per day. After this point, my weaker ankle simply became too strained and unsure footing 30′ on a ladder is not what is considered desirous. This became exponentially problematic as the task wore on and I needed to take 1 or more days off after a 5 hour session to heal (see examples of inefficiency #2, #3 in previous section). That said, my pecs, shoulders and arms looked glorious afterwards and I dropped 6 pounds as I hobbled about with a gimpy gait secretly wishing I had a walking frame.
RESPECT & GRATITUDE
Aside from this crash course in humility, I also came away with a profound sense of respect and gratitude. Respect not only for myself having completed the project, but for others who do the same day-in and day-out. Construction, even painting, is not physically easy and is certainly demanding on one’s body. For those who do this sort of work as a career, my hat’s off to them.
I am also extremely grateful that I am fortunate enough to have the time to undertake and complete such a project. It was arduous (as expected), but worth the while. Now, every time I look at my house (which is every day) I think, “Yep, I painted that sucker all by myself. By hand, mofo!” Like anything you accomplish on your own, it’s a magnificent feeling.
SO, WOULD I EVER DO THIS AGAIN?
I’ve spent more than a few hours contemplating this question and my answer is, unquestionably, yes. With provisos. Using scaffolding and having another person assist are at the top of the list. Honestly, for less than $500 I could have had both and the project done in about 60% less time and 85% less wear on my ankle. I was simply being lazy and cheap there and I paid a much larger cost for doing so. The sprayer is a distant second, but I may give it a whirl next time around (10 years or so) after learning and practicing a bit. And, if I’m honest, so long as I have the time & physical wherewithal, paying $175 an hour for painting will never be okay, unless of course it’s you paying me for that service.
WAIT, WAS THERE ANY ZEN?
I think the only thing I actually do enjoy about painting by myself is that it does offer a certain, peculiar level of tranquility where I can get into a bit of a zen-state and just be. Sometimes being exclusively focused on the basic task at hand all thoughts, cares and worries cast asunder is a beautiful place to be. I also found this level of monk-like calm was a requirement high atop the ladder, cold wind bellowing down upon me and not thinking about soiling myself.
So there you have it. I’ve got to get rolling now as I need to work on planning trtheip to Japan. Bring on the sushi!
BONUS IRONIC EPILOGUE
Despite over 30 hours of standing on all manner of ladders at a number of different heights during the project, I never had a slip, fall or any other specimen of mishap, even when the pain in my ankle was excruciating and I could barely walk. Ironically, it was last week that I fell from a 7′ ladder when trimming tree branches at my folk’s place. Thankfully, what with being only 32 and all, I walked away from that with only a torqued knee and a slightly bruised ego.
HOW ABOUT YOU?
Ever painted your house? Engaged in a large-scale home improvement project? How’d it go? What did you learn? I’d love to hear your thoughts.
Great way to break down the cost savings. I’d say you earned that Ritz suite in Tokyo!
Thanks IF, it was my way of creating an artificial forced choice situation which I knew would prevent me from grumbling and complaining during the project. Haha. Here’s hoping that Japan will even let us in next year.
I had images of Daniel-san and Mr. Miyagi saying, “Wax on, wax off” while reading this post. Between the Tokyo Ritz, sushi, and finally discovering the zen-like nature of painting, it’s a lot like their story! 😉 Nice job on both the work and major cost savings. When’s the trip to Tokyo? I think you’ve earned it.
Hiyas and thanks for the comment! Yep, when writing this I also had the Karate Kid thing going on in my head. I tried to work in a “paint on, paint off” type pin but couldn’t seem to make it work.
I have a brick house so no need to paint the outside but my fascia boards are wooden and starting to chip away. Last time I paid to have them done but now I have a proper ladder and will probably do them myself. Last time I was also working 40 hrs a week, and now I’m not 🙂
Hey dave and thanks for the comment t. Yep, the the free time and a good ladder, you’re all set. It’s a nice feeling to do it on your own.
Bravo! We’ve always done our own painting, because of the massive markup that you alluded to. In fact, we painted almost the entirety of our house over the last 6 months in preparation for selling it. However, I’ve never painted the exterior of a home, and I imagine that’s a lot more tedious. By the way, when we finished our basement a few years ago, my wife purchased a cheap sprayer. It worked really well, and was not difficult to figure out. The only drawback was that it used a bit more paint and was quite messy, but all-in-all I think we were pretty satisfied with the choice.
Hey Adam and thanks for the comment. I was curious about exterior painting and I’m here to tell you it’s waaaaaaay more forgiving than interior. If you’re good at interior, then you’ll be great at exterior. Much easier IMHO.
Yeah, many others have said the same about the sprayer being very easy to learn. I’m going to paint my folk’s place next Spring and decided to use one (along with scaffolding and a lil’ help of course).
So you found your new side hustle – “Fates on Fire Painting Company”… hahaha.
This shit is pretty funny and absolutely relevant to me. As you know, for my house shopping search coming up, painting will be a big topic. My sister just bought a condo and I was helping her pick out paint samples last week. She decided to hire a painter, because she would never do it on her own anyway, which is the perfectly right choice for her. But this started my thinking on what I would do in her situation, and for my soon to be new house, which will be an interesting decision.
I’m more like you, in that I’m telling my wife I can do it myself. Then she tells me I’m an idiot and should just pay to have it done professionally so I don’t fuck it up and for the “time” factor you mention.
I also think for me, the point you bring up on safety would be the biggest factor. I don’t mind spending money on something that I’m not used to doing, and I have spent a lot of time on ladders this past year and have a better understanding of the risk – one bad fall and you’re easily toast.
But, I’ve written my own post on the satisfaction of doing something yourself. So I think in your situation of having the time to learn and do the work, you had a good time and made the right decision for you. Who would have thought painting could be so interesting?
Thanks, as always, for the comment Q-FI. Yeah, who knew it could be so entertaining. I was there laughing at myself the whole time thinking, this is too damned ridiculous not to share and what with the financial/frugality aspect, it just had to happen. Haha!
I’d say with your current situation, just hire it out, if for no other reason than the prep work being horrific. If you wanted to do a hybrid, you could GC the thing and get a few solid day workers and pay them well to help. That’d save you 50% easily and you could get it done in a couple/few weekends.
outstanding. i’m glad you got ‘er done and “captured some key learnings” along the way. you like that corporate speak? i got a real future ahead of me! now you have shamed me into painting our place next time. i ought to be retired in 15 years when it will need it but then again i’ll be 67.
i have to agree with one big point you make about the satisfaction in doing this job. my little stint in manufacturing on the factory floor was probably below my skill level but then again at the end of a shift there was a huge pile of well made valuable product. that always felt pretty sweet.
Call me Mr. Got’Er Did! Yeah, that ridiculous corporate speak is a hard disease to shake haha! You’ll be in fine shape at 67, my dude, just be sure to get a few lower paid assistants and you’re golden!
Totally agree on the self-satisfaction. I did all of the landscaping, fence building, sprinkler system, blah on our So. Cal and it’s that same good feeling every time you look at it.